Tried fresh, human-grade food for your dog yet? 60% Off First Order at Ollie. Redeem Offer

Redbarn Dog Food Reviews 2024: Simply the Best?

Written by

Ma. Leonor Dollisen

Reviewed by

Updated on:

Some articles include affiliate links, and we may receive compensation when you make a purchase through these links.
redbarn dog food reviews

Meet Redbarn Dog Food

Redbarn Dog Food started its journey in Canada and has expanded over the years to include nine buildings for manufacturing and a plant in Paraguay.

The company’s founders created Redbarn out of their love for animals and produce high-quality foods that help dogs improve digestion and maintain vigor.

Redbarn has a wide range of products, but its mainstay is the famed Redbarn bully stick. You’ve probably seen those, but the brand’s foods could also be next on your list for your furry companion.

Let’s take a look at the recipes and see if they’re your next solution. Below is our comprehensive Redbarn Dog Food Reviews.


Here at DogFood.Guide we have a dedicated mission to provide dog owners like you with well-researched information so they can provide the nutrition and health care towards their dogs.

Our readers rely upon our dog food articles, reviews and recall alerts that we took the time to research. We also routinely update and review our own reviews ensuring that any changes by manufacturers are brought to your attention.

DogFood.Guide is maintained by Mary Nielsen & her staff. Mary is an advocate and lover. She and her staff are passionate about animals and work hard to provide you with a wealth of information for you and your dog.

Our site is supported by our readers. If you make a purchase through one of our links, we may earn a referral fee. This helps cover the cost of operating our free blog. Thanks for your support!

Brand Quick Look

  • Redbarn Dog FoodParent Company: Redbarn
  • Founded in: 1996
  • Made in: Kansas
  • Available at:  Chewy, Amazon, Redbarn
  • Types of Food: Rolled, Canned & Dry Dog Food
  • Real Meat in First 5 Ingredients? : Yes
  • Recalled in Past? : No

Behind the Brand

Redbarn was started by two friends who played hockey together in Canada. After a few separate business ventures, the pair decided that their mutual love of animals made them the perfect people to start a new dog food company.

The company worked out of makeshift manufacturing facilities (i.e., their garages) for a while, but the pair soon relocated to California to be closer to the bulk of their customers. They expanded into a second build and then another until they were working out of nine buildings.

They began looking for a much larger facility, settling on a former plant in Kentucky with a built-in water system that helped return only clean water to the earth after manufacturing. Now, they manufacture all their recipes from this plant and use only manufacturing best practices to produce safe meals for dogs.

The company expanded recently into a bully factory in Paraguay to increase the quality of production. Having those types of connections allows the company to increase production without compromising quality.

Redbarn Dog Food Reviews

Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 2
Redbarn Lamb Roll
  • Suitable for all life stages
  • Comprised with 50% lamb and lamb lung
  • Highly versatile (can be used as meal, treat or topper)
Check Price on ChewyCheck Price on Redbarn
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 3
Redbarn Beef Roll
  • Contains essential vitamins and minerals
  • High-quality beef is the very first ingredient
  • With flaxseed for magnesium, iron, calcium supplement
Check Price on ChewyCheck Price on Redbarn
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 4
Redbarn Grain-Free Chicken Roll
  • Made from 50% fresh, high quality meat
  • Formula is highly palatable and easily digested
  • Great for pet parents concerned with allergies, obesity, or digestibility
Check Price on ChewyCheck Price on Redbarn
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 5
Redbarn Naturals Beef Pate
  • Ingredient starts with high-quality beef
  • Supports optimal health, promotes healthy skin, coat, and joints
  • With beef liver for added flavor
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 6
Redbarn Grain-Free Ocean Fish Pate
  • Contains fish broth for added flavor and aroma
  • Great source of protein, fiber, and carbohydrates
  • Enough calories to gain healthy weight
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 7
Redbarn Grain-Free Turkey Stew
  • Crafted with wholesome and hand-selected ingredients
  • Starts with turkey as an excellent source of protein
  • No grains, carrageenan, or anything artificial
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 8
Redbarn Wildwood Quail Stew Recipe
  • Contains real quail, an excellent novel protein
  • Packed with essential nutrients
  • Formulated in a delectable, lip-smacking gravy
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 9
Redbarn Chicken Pate for Joint Health
  • Crafted to combat bone and joint issues
  • Contains anti-inflammatory properties
  • Zero fillers or animal by-products
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 10
Redbarn Lamb Pate For Skin & Coat Health
  • Starts with lamb as the dominant protein
  • Specially crafted to improve skin and coat
  • A limited ingredient recipe ideal for food-sensitive dogs
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 11
Redbarn Whole Grain Ocean Recipe
  • First 5 Ingredients are impressively animal proteins
  • Helps support the overall wellbeing of canines
  • All natural, carefully selected ingredients
Check Price on ChewyCheck Price on Redbarn
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 12
Redbarn Grain-Free Land Recipe
  • Contains drool-worthy beef and lamb
  • Keeps immune system stronger
  • Guaranteed satisfaction for meat-loving canines
Check Price on ChewyCheck Price on Redbarn
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 13
Redbarn Whole Grain Sky Recipe
  • Multi-protein recipe that starts with real turkey
  • Each kibble is full of prebiotics and probiotics for digestion
  • Wholesome grains supply carbohydrates for energy
Check Price on ChewyCheck Price on Redbarn
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 14
Redbarn Bully Sticks Beef
  • Promotes dental health by cleaning his teeth and gums
  • Cranberries, blueberries, vitamin E and chicken cartilage
  • All-natural cowhide is coated in Redbarn’s secret bully gravy
Check Price on ChewyCheck Price on Redbarn
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 15
Redbarn Large Peanut Butter Filled Bone
  • Made with real peanut butter
  • Each large bone measures about 6 inches
  • Keeps your dog busy and preoccupied
Check Price on ChewyCheck Price on Redbarn
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 16
Redbarn Cheese n' Bacon Filled Cow Hooves
  • Each hoof is filled with oozing goodness
  • Safe, natural and delicious treat full of amazing flavor
  • All-natural bone to chew on after the filling is all gone
Check Price on ChewyCheck Price on Redbarn

Reviewed Redbarn Dog Foods

  1. Redbarn Lamb Roll
  2. Redbarn Beef Roll
  3. Redbarn Grain-Free Chicken Roll
  4. Redbarn Naturals Beef Pate
  5. Redbarn Grain-Free Ocean Fish Pate
  6. Redbarn Grain-Free Turkey Stew
  7. Redbarn Wildwood Quail Stew Recipe
  8. Redbarn Chicken Pate for Joint Health
  9. Redbarn Lamb Pate For Skin & Coat Health
  10. Redbarn Whole Grain Ocean Recipe
  11. Redbarn Grain-Free Land Recipe
  12. Redbarn Whole Grain Sky Recipe
  13. Redbarn Bully Sticks Beef
  14. Redbarn Large Peanut Butter Filled Bone
  15. Redbarn Cheese n' Bacon Filled Cow Hooves
Get 60% off your first order


1. Redbarn Lamb Roll

Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

First Five Ingredients:

  • Lamb
  • Lamb Lung
  • Brown Rice
  • Rice Flour
  • Lamb Liver
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 17
Specially made for supplemental feeding only, this rolled food can be stored in a dry, cool place prior to opening. Made from real lamb and lamb organ boasting 50% protein content plus a blend of garden veggies and fruits for superior nutrition.

Lamb is a rich source of protein, and this roll is over 50% lamb. Whole lamb plus organ meat offers a dense source of protein and fats that can give your dog energy all day long.

Most dogs love the taste of lamb, and the roll has a pleasing, crumbly texture that can encourage even picky or senior dogs to eat everything.

Other ingredients include whole fruits and vegetables for essential vitamins and minerals. The recipe also includes a vitamin pre-mix to ensure balanced nutrition.

It does contain peas, which could make some dog owners nervous because of a suspected link to an enlarged heart, but peas don’t make it into the top five ingredients.

Chewy Online Dog Supplies

30% Off at

+ Free Shipping

Save Now

The rolls are convenient to store and serve. They’re shelf stable in a cool place until you’ve opened them so you won’t have to take up your entire fridge just to store your dog food. When you serve, you cube the portions, so there are no messy liquids that can cause spills.

Most dogs love the texture, and with the blessing of your vet, this could be a good option for puppies or seniors that have trouble chewing kibbles.

Overall, it’s a pretty good blend of ingredients from excellent sources. If you’ve been wanting something to spice up your dog’s meals or you need an option that isn’t a dry kibble, the rolls could be just the thing to get your dog’s diet back on track.

2. Redbarn Beef Roll

Rating: 5 out of 5 stars

First Five Ingredients:

  • Beef
  • Beef Lung
  • Beef Liver
  • Whole Wheat Flour
  • Egg Product
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 18
High-quality beef is the very first ingredient in every roll and accounts for over 50% of the entire recipe. Ideal for the dog with food sensitivities or allergies.

Beef is one of the most popular meats in dog foods and a favorite among canines. It’s the very first ingredient here, and it accounts for more than 50% of the recipe. Beef is a high-quality meat that contains all the essential amino acids your pup needs. 

We like that the food contains a lot of meat, not only to give your pup enough energy to last him throughout the day but also to make the food more filling for him.

It doesn’t contain any veggies which we’d have liked to see, although it has flaxseed. Flaxseed contains a heavy load of magnesium, iron, calcium, vitamin B-6, and omega fatty acids.

It is formulated with a single protein only, which makes it ideal for pups who are sensitive to specific types of animal protein. So if your pet is not allergic to beef, then this food might be suited to him.

As for the food itself, the rolls have a dense texture that you can easily cut through to get the desired shape or size (if you want to use it as a training treat or to give to little pups), but it can crumble when pressed hard. There’s a smoky smell, so perhaps there’s a smoky flavor too. 

With 550 reviews under its belt and 92% of reviewers saying they recommend the food, we know that this food is highly liked by dogs.

Looking at the ingredients, we can’t find any troubling ingredients either. We might wish for a little fruit or vegetable but that’s about it. 

3. Redbarn Grain-Free Chicken Roll

Rating:  3.5 out of 5 stars

First Five Ingredients:

  • Chicken
  • Chicken Liver
  • Chicken Hearts
  • Chickpeas
  • Sucrose
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 19
Highly versatile – can be used as a complete and balanced meal, a protein supplement to dry food, as a treat, training tool, or as an aid for administering medications.

This recipe is Redbarn’s answer to dogs who are sensitive to grains but who would benefit from the brand’s meaty diet. Unlike the other formulations for Redbarn’s meat rolls, the Grain-Free Chicken Roll uses sweet potatoes and peas in place of grain ingredients.

There is no need to worry about the amount of legumes or sweet potatoes in this diet. The different chicken meats in this food make up over 50% of the total diet.

Even if you see chickpeas in the top five ingredients, the volume of legumes doesn't overwhelm the meat.

Unlike its beef counterpart, this Chicken Roll contains vegetables but no corn, wheat, grain, or soy to cause any allergic reaction or digestibility problems in sensitive pups.

However, it does contain sucrose, which is a form of sugar. The brand explains that it uses sucrose to preserve the meat naturally but there shouldn’t be enough of it to place in the top five.

The texture of the food is soft, although some reviewers say that it is also crumbly and quite dry.

The non-gooey texture makes it easier to feed as a training treat, to bring on travels, or to place on top of regular dog food as a topper. For main meals, it can be a bit too dry, which may turn some pups off.

Out of 64 reviews, only 72% recommend the food, mostly because of the texture. We have found no problems with the ingredients except for one — the sucrose.

While it enhances palatability and helps in preserving food, sucrose can also contribute to tooth decay, hyperactivity, or obesity in your pup.

Taking the customer reviews and the ingredients into consideration, we give this recipe a passing mark.

4. Redbarn Naturals Beef Pate

Rating:  4.5 out of 5 stars

First Five Ingredients:

  • Beef
  • Beef Broth
  • Beef Liver
  • Dried Egg Product
  • Beef Pizzle
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 20
High-quality beef is the #1 ingredient in this complete and balanced food with added vitamins and minerals. Absolutely no carrageenan, artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives, so you can be confident you're feeding your pup the best.

The Grain-Free Beef Pate by Redbarn is a functional diet that is geared towards pups of all life stages. It is crafted to support optimal health, and promote healthy skin, coat, joints, and immune system. 

Redbarn reformulated this diet to make it a lot meatier than the previous formula. There is now beef liver in the first five ingredients. It still starts with beef, but now almost all of the main ingredients are meat, with the exception of beef broth. 

There is a good balance of meat and produce here. The recipe includes carrots and dandelion greens, the latter of which may sound odd as ingredients in dog food, but they’re a good contributor of proteins, vitamins, and minerals. They’re also considered good liver stimulants that may promote healthy waste elimination in your pup.

The recipe is in pate form that reviewers describe as “a good solid pate” that will work great as either the main meal or as a topper. It’s easy to digest and many dogs so far like the taste. Some have noted, though, that the pate may be a little thick for mixing. 

Out of 19 reviews, 95% recommend the food. We also can’t find anything we don’t like about the ingredients. It has all the right amount of nutrients and calories. It also doesn’t contain anything artificial or troubling ingredients like carrageenan.

5. Redbarn Grain-Free Ocean Fish Pate for Healthy Weight

Rating:  4 out of 5 stars

First Five Ingredients:

  • Ocean Fish
  • Fish Broth
  • Peas
  • Agar-Agar
  • Quinoa
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 21
Has high-quality ocean fish as the first ingredient. With chicory root extract that helps support the digestive system, while the coconut oil support a healthy immune system.

Dogs battling with obesity will need dog food that provides all of the nutrition they need but without the excess calories. The Grain-Free Fish Pate by the brand is perfect for this.

It uses high-quality ocean fish like mahi-mahi, grouper, cod, sole, halibut, and haddock (whichever are seasonally available) as the main ingredient. 

Fish are low in fat, nutritionally-rich, and are an easily digestive source of protein. They’re also fantastic sources of omega-3 fatty acids, which have anti-inflammatory properties that are great for dogs with allergies or intolerances. 

We like the inclusion of carrots, peas, dandelion greens, and quinoa. Since the food is grain-free, the quinoa provides the carbs.

It has a strong nutritional profile that makes it a healthy alternative to wheat, soy, or corn. Meanwhile, the veggies make this food a little more balanced.

Each 13 oz can only contains 376 kcal so your pup won’t gain too much even when he downs all of his food in one go. Dogs, when you by the reviews, seem to thrive on the diet. The formulation keeps them active while keeping down the weight. 

With a 97% recommended rating, many customers love it for their pets. Sensitive dogs have less or no more flare ups on this diet, pups have more energy, and it helps manage the weight of overweight-prone canines.

The only downside, some say, is the dry texture. However, that only means your pet is getting more product and less water in his food.

6. Redbarn Grain-Free Turkey Stew

Rating:  4.5 out of 5 stars

First Five Ingredients:

  • Turkey
  • Turkey Broth
  • Vegetable Broth
  • Turkey Liver
  • Natural Flavors
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 22
High-quality turkey is the #1 ingredient in this complete and balanced adult food with added vitamins and minerals. The chunky stew and highly palatable gravy will tempt any picky eaters.

The Grain-Free Turkey Stew is an all-natural dog food that’s made with wholesome and hand-selected ingredients. There are no grains, carrageenan, or anything artificial (colors, preservatives, and flavors). Just a complete balanced diet starring turkey as the main ingredient in a delicious gravy stew.

Turkey is an excellent source of protein and a great alternative to chicken, if your pet happens to be sensitive to chicken. It has all the essential nutrients pups need and it contains a similar macronutrient profile as chicken, although it has a lower calorific content than chicken.

We like the inclusion of veggies and fruits in this diet. There are dandelion greens, parsley, cranberries, peas, and sweet potatoes in it, all of which are excellent contributors of vitamins and minerals. And since the food is grain- and gluten-free, there is much less risk of food allergies.

Although this formulation only has 17 reviews on Chewy as of the moment, the reviewers have given it a 4.6 stars out of 5. 94% also give it a ‘recommended’ rating.

Some of the reasons why it rates high are: it’s gentle on dogs’ tummies; it has a nice consistency; good ingredients; and dogs love the flavor.

Based on customer reviews and our evaluation of the ingredients, we’d have to say that this recipe is indeed a good one to add to your pup’s dog food rotation.

7. Redbarn Wildwood Quail Stew Recipe

Rating:  5 out of 5 stars

First Five Ingredients:

  • Quail
  • Vegetable Broth
  • Water
  • Dried Egg Product
  • Natural Flavor
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 23
This savory stew features real quail as the first ingredient, served in a smooth gravy alongside nutritious veggies like peas, carrots and parsley.

Every dog has an inner wolf that loves prey animals, yes, even the sensitive pups. This Redbarn stew recipe provides dogs with game bird meat with its star ingredient — quail. Quail is not often seen in dog food, making it a novel protein that may suit your sensitive pet. 

If you haven’t encountered quail in dog food yet, it’s one of several options that’s being billed as alternative animal proteins.

Quail is a relatively lean and low-calorie option for canines but high in essential nutrients, especially phosphorus and iron, both of which play a big role in muscle development.

The recipe is meaty with quail making up a huge bulk of the meal. Peas, carrots, and dandelion greens only act as support to provide naturally-sourced nutrition and a more wholesome flavor to the stew. There are also superfoods included, such as turmeric and salmon oil, which supports healthy skin and a lavish coat.

There are only two customer reviews as of now on for this formulation, but both rate the food as 5 stars out of 5.

They highly recommend the food because it’s a non-chicken diet (sensitive pet owner) that’s lean and healthy and also because it looks and smells appealing, unlike other dog food. It’s also reportedly easy to transition to as well.

Because it’s a complete and balanced diet, rated highly by consumers, and uses only premium quality ingredients, we will also rate this food with top marks.

8. Redbarn Chicken Pate for Joint Health

Rating:  5 out of 5 stars

First Five Ingredients:

  • Chicken
  • Chicken Broth
  • Chicken Liver
  • Peas
  • Dried Egg Product
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 24
Chicken is the #1 ingredient in this complete and balanced adult food with added vitamins and minerals. Functional ingredients have also been added to support your dog's overall health.

Some dogs are more prone to joint problems than other dogs. For example, bigger breeds will usually exert more pressure on their joints than smaller pooches.

Aging is also another factor when it comes to bone and joint issues, since bones tend to get more brittle and joints become more inflexible the older  a pup gets.

This recipe focuses on supporting canine joints. The green-lipped mussels that are included in the diet are known for their inflammatory properties (for arthritis), chondroitin and glucosamine content, and their unique combination of omega fatty acids that support joint health.

Chicken is the main ingredient and almost all other meat ingredients are made from it. If you’ll check the nutritional label, the protein content is indicated to be at a minimum of 10% — higher than the content of the other Redbarn canned recipes. This is because chicken is one of the best sources of animal protein. 

There are carrots, peas, and dandelion greens included to provide added nutrition and balance to the meal. Those nutrients that cannot be sourced naturally are supplemented instead by the brand. 

This is one of the best-ranking canned recipes by Redbarn. It has 16 reviews and all are favorable. 100% of reviewers also recommend the food to other pet parents.

Most are happy that their pets love the taste of the food, but a few have also reported that the diet has helped their dogs become a lot more active. The smooth consistency of the pate also got a thumbs up.

It’s kind of rare to see dog food without negative reviews, but this recipe has done it. We can’t argue with the reviews and the ingredients that we can see, so we’re giving this formulation our highest rating.

9. Redbarn Lamb Pate for Skin & Coat Health

Rating:  4.5 out of 5 stars

First Five Ingredients:

  • Lamb
  • Lamb Broth
  • Lamb Liver
  • Dried Egg Product
  • Peas
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 25
High-quality lamb is the #1 ingredient in this complete and balanced dog food with added vitamins and minerals. With brewers yeast that is rich in antioxidants that may reduce itchy, dry skin.

For some reason or another, a dog’s skin and coat may look dull and unhealthy. Allergies and sensitivities are usually the culprit, although lack of proper nutrition can do that too.

This Redbarn Lamb Pate is dedicated to providing optimal nutrition to pups while also supporting lustrous hair and healthy skin.

The number one ingredient in this recipe is, of course, lamb. Lamb is pretty similar to beef in nutrition, except lamb has more omega-3 fatty acids. It also contains a good amount of iron, B vitamins (B2, B3, B5, B6, and B12), and zinc. 

There are three kinds of fat ingredients here. Salmon oil, coconut oil, and sunflower oil provide not only energy but the right amount of omegas to keep your dog’s skin healthy (and itch-free) and his hair shiny and lustrous.

Salmon oil has omega-3s, coconut oil soothes the digestive system and helps with nutrient absorption, and sunflower oil has omega-6s that keeps skin moisturized.

The texture of the pate is smooth with a rich and dense consistency. The vegetables are recognizable, and you can see some small chunks of them in the food. 

Customers rate this formulation with 4.4 stars out of 5, and it’s recommended by 89% of reviewers. The favorable reviews talk about how even finicky dogs lick their bowls clean when provided this food.

Chewy Online Dog Supplies

30% Off at

+ Free Shipping

Save Now

The negative reviews, on the other hand, are about a few different things like the consistency (hard, one said) and how a pet did not touch the food when given. 

Not all dogs will like the same thing, but many pups like this recipe more than those who don’t. But we do consider the customer feedback when rating food (within reason).

Based on customer feedback and also our review of the diet, we still think this deserves a place within your regular canned dog food rotation.

10. Redbarn Whole Grain Ocean Recipe

Rating:  5 out of 5 stars

First Five Ingredients:

  • Salmon
  • Trout
  • Salmon Meal
  • Ocean Fish Meal
  • Menhaden Fish Meal
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 26
Each scoop of this dry recipe contains carefully selected functional ingredients. With added omega 6 and 3 fatty acids from salmon oil and flaxseeds help support healthy skin and a beautiful, shiny coat

This Whole Grain Ocean Recipe is a fish feast for pups. It’s a functional diet that is headlined by five kinds of fish proteins to provide your canine with a beautiful coat and healthy skin. 

Fish is an excellent source of omega fatty acids, and these ocean fish are particularly oily, meaning they contain an abundance of omegas. Not only that, because the first five ingredients are fish, the protein content of the meal is at a high 27% minimum.

A few healthy grains like oatmeal, brown rice, barley and millet provide the carbohydrate content. There are probiotics, prebiotics, and miscanthus grass to aid your dog’s digestion. Dried pumpkin and supplemental vitamins and minerals provide all the required vitamins and minerals.

100% of reviewers recommend this food to other pet owners. According to reports, picky dogs have no problem licking their bowls clean. Even pups who are mostly fed raw diets don’t hesitate to eat this fishy diet when offered. 

We’d have to give this superb diet our top marks for scoring high in customer feedbacks and containing nothing but premium quality ingredients.

11. Redbarn Grain-Free Land Recipe

Rating:  5 out of 5 stars

First Five Ingredients:

  • Beef
  • Lamb
  • Lamb Meal
  • Beef Meal
  • Pork Meal
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 27
This grain-free recipe help support your dog’s overall health, wellness, and longevity into their senior years. With pumpkin, prebiotics, and probiotics help support healthy digestion.

Combining three types of land animal proteins and filling in the first five slots of the list wholly with meats, this recipe promises to make meat-loving canines extremely happy.

The diet is functional too since it supports a healthy digestive system and contains guaranteed levels of methionine, l-carnitine, and taurine (for heart health).

Instead of grains, the formulation uses potatoes, garbanzo beans, peas, and sweet potatoes to provide the necessary carbohydrate content.

Now there’s no need to worry about DCM (legumes and potatoes have been linked with DCM occurrence in dogs) because these ingredients only play a supporting role and are not considered the main ingredients here.

Because of the high volume of meats included, the protein level of the food is also high at 16% minimum. There are also guaranteed levels of vitamins, omega fatty acids, and probiotics in the meal.

Out of the 50 people who reviewed this product, 96% recommend it. So far, there are no negative reviews and only one 3-star rating.

Many are happy that their pets’ coats seem healthier and shinier. Dogs also love the taste and don’t have to be given toppers to finish their doggie bowls. 

Because we’ve reviewed the label and did not see any problematic ingredients, nor seen any bad feedbacks (all feedbacks were glowing), we highly recommend this recipe for your pet too.

12. Redbarn Whole Grain Sky Recipe

Rating:  5 out of 5 stars

First Five Ingredients:

  • Turkey
  • Chicken
  • Duck Meal
  • Turkey Meal
  • Chicken Meal
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 28
Packed with meat in the first five ingredients, this recipe has guaranteed methionine, taurine & l-carnitine to support heart health and vitamins A & E help support a healthy immune system.

If your dog loves poultry meat, he’ll find great satisfaction in the Whole Grain Sky recipe. It’s packed with meat in the first five ingredients and there are three kinds.

Each scoop of kibble contains functional ingredients like prebiotics and probiotics for digestion; omega 3 and 6 fatty acids for shiny coats; and taurine, methionine, and l-carnitine for heart health.

High-quality grains like barley, oatmeal, brown rice, milo, and millet are used to supply the carbohydrate content of the food. Carbs are the first used-up macronutrient (fat and protein come next) when dogs need energy, so it’s an essential part of any dog food diet. 

The crude protein level of this recipe is at a minimum of 26%, which is considered at the upper end of average. The menhaden fish meal, which isn’t included in the first five ingredients, also lends its protein support. 

93% of consumers gave this diet a 5-star rating, while the rest gave it a 4-star. Most are happy that their pups love the taste and flavor of this diet, but some are pleased that their pets’ digestive issues have cleared up with the Whole Grain Sky Recipe.

We’re happy with the selection of ingredients here. Even the grains used are high-quality and not the cheap ones like brewer’s rice, which are found in many other dog food diets.

And based on many feedbacks, the dogs are thriving on this diet. We’re giving it top marks.

Dog Treat Reviews

1. Redbarn Bully Sticks Beef

Rating:  2 out of 5 stars

First Five Ingredients:

  • Beef Ear
  • Beef Hide
  • Beef Liver
  • Egg Whites
  • Beef Pizzle
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 29
All-natural cowhide is coated in their secret bully gravy and then slow roasted to lock in all that irresistible flavor. This irresistible treat keeps your pup entertained for hours and helps reduce boredom and anxiety.

Dogs love to chew, and the Bully Sticks provide them with natural but long-lasting treats they can nibble on. The food is made of beef rawhide packed with flavor from beef parts, fruits, and chicken cartilage. 

The all natural cowhide is coated in the bully gravy for more flavor. It’s fully digestible and contains nutrients for joint health and mobility.

It does not contain grains or glutens. What it does have are dried cranberries and dried blueberries for their vitamin and mineral content.

The Bully Sticks are extremely popular with 605 reviews to date and a score of 4.4 stars out of 5. The reviews are mixed, although there are more favorable than negative. Dogs of all sizes are reported to enjoy the treats and will stay up all night just to chew. 

On our end, however, we have to say that we are not in favor of rawhide treats for all dogs. In fact, rawhides are quite dangerous for some pets.

The chews may start out hard but constant chewing can give them the consistency of a bubble gum, which makes them an intestinal and choking hazard.

Dogs who are not heavy chewers should not have a problem with rawhide. But dogs who are strong chewers are particularly at risk since they may bite off a larger chunk which can then cause an obstruction in their esophagus or intestinal tract. The chunks won’t be broken down with the rest of your dog’s food and may even last for months in his stomach.

Since these treats carry such a risk, we can’t rate them high to be safe. (Also, the treats contain fructose as well as caramelized sugar, which are not ideal in food or in treats.)

2. Redbarn Large Peanut Butter Filled Bone

Rating: 3.5  out of 5 stars

First Five Ingredients:

  • Beef Bone
  • Corn Syrup
  • Water
  • Chicken Meal
  • Sugar
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 30
This treat combines white, cut femur bones and a wholesome, peanutty mixture. Helps promote dental health, hard exterior helps clean teeth as pet chews.

Bones are natural treats that dogs love. They come with benefits too, such as preventing plaque buildup through chewing. Dogs that are chewing on bones are also less likely to excessively scratch or lick paws.

Redbarn made bone treats more interesting by filling beef bones with delicious stuffing that’s also filled with nutrients. Inside the beef bones are stuffings with peanut butter, chicken meal, and more.

According to reviews, the bones are very sturdy and can withstand lots of chewing. Once the filling is gone, you can refill them again with stuffing of your own choosing.

However, some have also said to watch the bones carefully. After a while of chewing, pieces of bone might break off which your pup could swallow. 

As for us, we’re fine with natural bone chews. However, what we do not like is that the first filling ingredient is corn syrup. That’s just another form of sugar.

What's more worrying is that  the fourth ingredient is also sugar. Dogs that frequently consume sugar on a regular basis are at risk for diabetes and obesity. 

The recipe also contains artificial colors, which are not necessary. It has titanium dioxide and Yellow 6. Artificial colors do not benefit dogs. Their only purpose is to make the food more appealing to pet owners.

3. Redbarn Cheese n' Bacon Filled Cow Hooves

Rating:  3 out of 5 stars

First Five Ingredients:

  • Natural Beef Hoof
  • Corn Syrup
  • Chicken Broth
  • Chicken Meal
  • Sugar
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 31
These natural cow hooves are cleaned, trimmed and stuffed with a tasty cheese n’ bacon filling – an irresistible, highly palatable treat your dog will absolutely love!

Cow hooves are durable and palatable treats that dogs like to chew on. This recipe is made of natural cow hooves that have been cleaned, trimmed and stuffed. The fillings are a tasty mixture of chicken meal and bacon bits with a cheesy flavor.

These chewy treats have 161 reviews on Chewy as of this moment with a rating of 4.2 stars out of 5. Many pet owners have reported that their pups love chewing on these. And once the fillings are gone, the hooves are easily refillable with canned food or other stuffing.

On our end, we’d like to caution customers about the treats. Hooves can be safe but it all depends upon your dog’s level of chewing.

Pieces that break off can be sharp and may be a hazard for your dog’s mouth and digestive tract. In fact, some of the reviews already tell of sharp pieces breaking off and lodging themselves into dogs’ mouths and gums. 

If your pet is a strong chewer with powerful jaws, it might be best to steer clear of the hooves. If your pet can chew lightly without crunching down excessively, then these might be fine., although we personally wouldn’t take the risk.

Aside from the possible danger posed by the hooves, we also have to point out that the ingredients of the filling are not to our liking.

The main ingredient of the filling is corn syrup, which is sugar. There’s also another sugar ingredient in the fourth slot, which means you’re giving your pet a very sweet treat that might put him at risk for obesity. 

Apart from the sugar, the treats also contain two other unsuitable ingredients. There are two artificial food colorings involved — Yellow 5 and Yellow 6.

Get 60% off your first order


What Types of Food Does Redbarn Offer?

Redbarn makes four types of dog foods along with their numerous treats. The company offers rolled, canned, dry, and air dried dog food choices.

Rolled: The “rolled” food or semi-moist food is a step between canned foods and kibbles, designed for convenience and taste. The brand’s rolled foods are single protein varieties and suitable for serving alone or as a supplement. There are grain-inclusive and grain-free choices.

Canned: Canned foods are also high-quality proteins that are suitable for solo or supplemental feedings. They’re formulated for all life stages, but you should check with your veterinarian before feeding your puppy, just to make sure the ingredients line up. As of this writing, all of Redbarn’s canned food are grain-free.

Dry: There are three basic recipes for kibbles that Redbarn offers. These are Land (3 types of meat), Ocean (5 types of fish), and Air (3 types of poultry). All of these have grain-inclusive and grain-free options.

A new line of food is also coming soon. Called Gently Air Dried Dog Food, these feature slow-cooked foods that are made up of 90% beef, chicken, or fish. The foods will be all-natural and grain-free and balanced with wholesome ingredients like flaxseed, salmon oil, and miscanthus grass.

All styles of foods provide balanced nutrition and all the building blocks for health and wellbeing. There are a range of proteins designed to help ease digestion and satisfy even picky dogs.

The foods use no artificial preservatives. There are no artificial colors or flavors that can encourage dogs to overeat or cause reactions.

The recipe uses no cheap fillers such as corn or soy which can also cause difficult digestion and skin irritations in dogs. Wholesome ingredients and whole meats are used for proteins, giving dogs energy all day.

Premium Rolled Food:

  • Beef
  • Chicken
  • Lamb
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 32

Premium Grain-Free Rolled Foods:

  • Chicken
  • Beef

Canned Foods Stew Recipes:

  • Beef
  • Chicken
  • Lamb
  • Turkey
  • Steak and Egg
  • Duck
  • Quail
  • Trout
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 33

Canned Foods Pate Recipes:

  • Duck and Turkey
  • Beef
  • Lamb
  • Chicken
  • Ocean Fish

Dry Dog Foods:

  • Whole Grain Ocean
  • Whole Grain Land
  • Whole Grain Sky
  • Grain-Free Ocean
  • Grain-Free Land
  • Grain-Free Sky

Air Dried Recipes:

  • Chicken
  • Beef
  • Fish
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 34



  • Meaty Bone
  • Filled Bone Peanut Butter
  • White Bone
  • Filled Bone Chicken
  • Filled Bone Cheese & Bacon
  • Filled Bone Beef
  • Filled Bone Lamb
  • Natural Filled Bone Chicken & Apple
  • Natural Filled Bone Cheese & Bacon
  • Knee Caps
  • Natural Filled Bone Peanut Butter
  • Filled Hoof Peanut Butter
  • Filled Hoof Beef
  • Shank Bone 
  • Meaty Knuckle Bone
  • Filled Hoof Cheese & Bacon
  • Bully Coated Large Bone
  • Duo Filled Bone Peanut Butter & Jelly
  • Natural Filled Hoof Bully Flavor
  • X-Large Ham Bone
  • Mammoth Bone

Chewy Online Dog Supplies

30% Off at

+ Free Shipping

Save Now

Bully Sticks

  • Bully Stick
  • Braided Bully Stick
  • Odor-Free Bully Stick
  • Bully Rings
  • Bully Barbells
  • Bully Spring
  • Odor-Free Braided Bully Stick
  • Bully Bites
  • Bully Tangle
  • Steer Sticks
  • Odor-Free Bully Spring
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 35


  • Barkey Bark Jerky
  • Beef Cheek Roll
  • Glazed Beef Cheek Rolls
  • Braided Stick
  • Beef Tendon
  • Bully Slims
  • Beef Cheek Spring
  • Bully Slices
  • Braided Ring
  • Elk Antler
  • The Bargain Bag
  • Puff Braid
  • Cow Tail
  • Barn Bagel Peanut Butter 
  • Bully Slices Peanut Butter
  • Natural Pig Ears
  • Cow Ears
  • Roofle
  • Esophagus Spring
  • Triple Twist
  • Beef Strap
  • Puffed Collagen Braid
  • Collagen Stick
  • Puffed Collagen Ring
  • Twizzle Stix
  • Piggy Puffs
  • Lamb Ear
  • Porky Slices
  • Jumbo Twister
  • Fletcher’s Braid
  • Filled Munchie Retriever
  • Pig Snouts
  • Smoked Pig Ears
Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 36

Dental Chews

  • Chew-A-Bulls Hydrant
  • Chew-A-Bulls Horned Toad
  • Chew-A-Bulls Ring
  • Chew-A-Bulls Brush
  • Chew-A-Bulls Shoe
  • Chew-A-Bulls Chip

The Redbarn Recall History

In early 2018, some of Redbarn’s treats were recalled for possible salmonella contamination. The recall involved several lots of Redbarn Naturals Bully Stick, Naturals Steer Stick, Chewy Louie Bully Stick, Good Lovin’ Bully Stick, Good Lovin’ Steer, Good Lovin’ Prime Cuts, Dentley’s Bully Stick, and Good Lovin’ XL Bully. 

The recall was limited to products that were distributed from March 2017-February 2018 with best by dates ending in “BC.”

No illnesses, injuries, or complaints were reported.

Customer Reviews

Customers love that Redbarn’s options are healthier and still premium without stressing their budgets. Dogs love the taste and texture of the rolls and respond really well to the canned options.

If your dog has a particular circumstance (joint issues, weight gain), you can still find a quality wet food that works for that situation without switching your dog to food it doesn’t like.

What Customers Like and Dislike about Redbarn?

Customers like the price of Redbarn a lot. It’s still a premium tier, but some of the options are better priced than other premium tiers. Also, there are so many options in protein sources and specific situations that it was easy for owners to find flavors their dogs liked.

Picky dogs could still get weight control options, for example, and none of the recipes use any kind of cheap filler, artificial ingredients, or unnamed meat meals and by-products.

The canned foods don’t use carrageenan, a conventional filler in wet foods, so customers were pleased by the quality of the ingredients.

Redbarn Dog Food Reviews [year]: Simply the Best? 37

Some dogs don’t always like the taste of specific proteins, so pet parents were stuck with some foods their dogs wouldn’t eat. Even when the food satisfies the majority of dogs, there will always be picky ones out there.

Some owners noted an increase in gas, which can happen with higher protein foods and some wet foods. Transition your dog slowly from the previous food to the new food to help ease digestion or change to a different protein source to help alleviate digestive issues. Most customers saw an improvement in digestion, however.

Customers really loved that the rolls were shelf stable until opened, making it so much easier to store them without having to take up the refrigerator. This is a unique feature of some rolled foods and one that’s a pleasant surprise for many customers.


“My 2 girls are both finicky eaters with semi-fragile digestive systems. I ordered the smaller packages of all 3 flavors for them to try as snacks. The lamb was the 2nd most loved. They had no problems with digesting this, no tummy upsets. This seems to have a perfect balance of moisture, not too dry, nor too wet.” Waninahi1,


“My picky little dog said “no” to this. It was worth the try. Smelled a bit artificial. I don't know how to explain my dog's preferences.” Dm63,

Redbarn dog food review

Are Redbarn dog treats safe?

Yes. Redbarn takes the safety of our products, pets, and customers as a number one concern. Redbarn employs an extensive Quality Assurance team that run over 400 safety tests on their products every week. All products are tested multiple times, for bacteria like Salmonella, coliforms, and enteros.

Who owns Red Barn food?

In 1996, Redbarn co-owners (and lifelong friends) Jeff Baikie and Howard Bloxam recognized the need for a wholesome dog food that was developed, produced and sold with integrity, honesty and, of course, premium ingredients.

Is Redbarn a good brand?

Redbarn Naturals Rolls lists both grain and grain-free semi-moist dog foods using a moderate amount of named meats as its main source of animal protein, thus earning the brand 2 stars from Dog Food Advisor.

Where are Redbarn dog treats made?

Redbarn uses high quality ingredients and the food is made and SOURCED in the USA.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

As you found this post useful...

Follow us on social media!

We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Let us improve this post!

Tell us how we can improve this post?

Scroll to Top