Newman’s Own Dog Food Review: Best High Quality Diet?

You are probably already familiar with the Newman’s Own company (especially their line of homemade salad dressings), but did you know that they also offer a selection of pet food products?

The Newman’s Own company offers a very limited selection of dry dog foods but a decent offering of wet food options, many of which are made with organic ingredients.

 

The products this brand has to offer are all centered around quality proteins like chicken, turkey, and beef with wholesome carbohydrates like brown rice and pearled barley.

When you feed your dog this brand, you can feel good that you are offering him a high-quality diet made with natural ingredients.

It might also please you to know that the company is dedicated to giving back – a full 100% of the profits from the sale of their products go to the Newman’s Own Foundation.

Who Makes Newman’s Own Dog Food?

The Newman’s Own brand of dog food is made by Newman’s Own, Inc. The Newman’s Own company was founded by Paul Newman in 1982 as a food and beverage company.

It all started with a homemade salad dressing that eventually led to pasta sauce, frozen pizzas, fruit juices, and other recipes.

In 1993, Newman’s daughter, Nell Newman, started an organic division of the company called Newman’s Own Organics which later became a separate company. Newman’s Own Organics includes a line of organic pet foods in addition to other food products.

Newman’s Own Dog Food Review

Though Newman’s Own may not offer the largest selection of dog food products, you can count on the fact that each recipe is made with high-quality ingredients.

Newman’s Own dry dog food only comes in two formulas, but both are made with protein-rich chicken and whole-grain carbohydrates as well as fresh fruits and veggies.

In terms of canned food, Newman’s Own offers a decent selection of organic wet food formulas made with premium proteins like chicken, turkey, and beef. These recipes also include digestible carbohydrates and healthy fats, as well as beneficial supplements.

Overall, the Newman’s Own brand offers a modest selection of high-quality products.

1. Dinner For Dogs Turkey & Brown Rice Recipe

First 5 ingredients: Organic Turkey, Organic Chicken, Water Sufficient for Processing, Poultry Liver and Organic Chicken Broth

Rating: 4/5

This is a grain-inclusive, 95% organic wet dog food designed for adult dogs of all breeds and sizes. This soft, easy-to-chew pate is ideal for senior dogs or those with dental issues.

It features real turkey and chicken as primary protein sources, with poultry liver adding rich flavor, though the specific animal source of the liver isn't specified.

The formula includes organic chicken broth for added moisture and flavor, making it suitable as a complete meal or kibble topper. Organic brown rice, sweet potatoes, and oat bran provide fiber-rich carbohydrates, promoting healthy digestion. Additionally, cranberries and dried kelp offer antioxidants and essential nutrients to support overall health.

While free from artificial enhancers, the recipe contains carrageenan, a thickening agent that some experts suggest may pose health risks. Despite this, the product is highly rated, with dogs enjoying its taste and being gentle on sensitive stomachs.

Overall, it’s a nutritious, meat-rich option for dogs who love turkey and chicken, though the presence of carrageenan may be a concern for some pet owners.

2. Newman's Own Organics Chicken & Liver Dinner

First 5 ingredients: Organic Chicken, Organic Chicken Broth, Organic Chicken Liver, Organic Pea Flour and Tricalcium Phosphate

Rating: 4.2/5

Another grain-free, high-protein wet food designed for adult dogs of all breeds, particularly those with allergies to grains, gluten, or non-chicken proteins.

The formula features organic chicken and chicken liver as its sole animal protein sources, making it a flavorful and easily digestible option for dogs. Organic chicken broth adds hydration, and organic pea flour serves as the primary carbohydrate, providing additional protein and nutrients.

The recipe is free from corn, wheat, soy, and artificial additives, though it does contain carrageenan, a thickening agent that some pet owners prefer to avoid due to potential health concerns.

This meat-rich, 95% organic pate is highly palatable and well-received by dogs, including picky eaters and seniors. However, the presence of carrageenan is a drawback for some.

3. Dinner For Dogs Turkey & Chicken Recipe

First 5 ingredients: Organic Turkey, Water Sufficient for Processing, Poultry Liver, Organic Chicken and Ocean Whitefish

Rating: 4/5

This is a grain-inclusive wet dog food suitable for adult dogs of all breeds and sizes. This multi-protein pate features organic turkey as the main protein source, supplemented by chicken, poultry liver, and ocean whitefish, making it highly palatable and easy to digest. The addition of whitefish provides omega fatty acids for skin and coat health.

The recipe includes wholesome grains like organic brown rice, which aids digestion, along with oat bran, carrots, and flaxseed, all contributing to overall health and well-being. Fortified with essential vitamins and minerals, it can be served as a complete meal or a hydrating kibble topper.

While it contains no artificial additives, it does include carrageenan, an ingredient some pet owners prefer to avoid. Despite this, the recipe is popular among dogs, especially picky eaters, thanks to its flavorful combination of poultry and ocean fish. Improvements could include more specific animal ingredient labeling and the removal of carrageenan.

4. Organic 95% Chicken Dinner

First 5 ingredients: Organic Chicken, Organic Chicken Broth, Organic Pea Flour, Dicalcium Phosphate and Calcium Carbonate

Rating: 4.2/5

This is a wet food made with organic ingredients, providing high nutritional value for dogs of all life stages. The primary ingredient is organic chicken, supported by organic chicken broth, which maintains a high moisture content of 78% and enhances the natural chicken flavor.

The main carbohydrate sources are organic pea flour and organic dried alfalfa, both of which also contribute plant-based protein. While this protein is less biologically valuable than animal protein, it's unclear how much it affects the total protein content.

The formula includes thickeners like guar gum and carrageenan, with the latter raising some concerns due to potential negative health effects, including links to cancer.

Despite these issues, the recipe is protein-rich and flavorful, though there's room for improvement, particularly by reducing reliance on plant proteins and removing carrageenan.

5. Beef Jerky Original Recipe

First 5 ingredients: Beef, Brown Sugar, Garlic Powder, Salt and Natural Flavor

Rating: 4.1/5

These treats are grain-free and made from grass-fed beef from New Zealand, suitable for dogs of all breeds and sizes. With a high protein content of 32%, these treats provide natural nutrients without added vitamins or minerals, as they are intended for occasional use rather than meal replacements.

The treats are naturally preserved and free from grains, wheat, corn, artificial colors, and flavor enhancers. They do contain brown sugar and garlic powder, which are safe in small amounts but should be given in moderation to avoid potential health issues like obesity or diabetes.

These bite-sized, chewy treats are popular among dog owners, especially for training rewards, though some find them too hard. Overall, they are appreciated for their high-quality beef and lack of fillers, making them ideal for dogs with sensitivities to non-beef proteins or grains.

However, some dogs may find the rich meat content too heavy for their stomachs.

6. Peanut Butter Flavor Biscuits

First 5 ingredients: Organic Barley Flour, Peanut Butter, Organic Carrots, Organic Apples and Chicken

Rating: 4.5/5

These treats are grain-inclusive, crunchy biscuits made with organic barley flour and flavored with both peanut butter and chicken. The treats also contain chicken fat for added taste and essential fatty acids.

Along with these flavors, the biscuits include superfoods like organic carrots, apples, and turmeric, which are rich in antioxidants that support immune and cellular health.

The heart-shaped biscuits are easy to break into smaller pieces, making them suitable as snacks or training rewards. They come in a resealable pouch to maintain freshness.

These treats are popular among dogs of all ages, particularly for their irresistible peanut butter and chicken combination. Dog owners appreciate their ease of use for training and their wholesome ingredients.

Additionally, buyers value that 100% of the profits from these treats go to charity, specifically to the Fidelco Guide Dog Foundation, which helps provide guide dogs to those who are blind.

Is this made in the United States?

The Newman’s Own company is headquartered in Westport, Connecticut. Research suggests that the brand makes all of their products in the United States, though no specific information is available. While the Newman’s Own company is fairly large, their pet food offerings are very limited.

Where Do They Get Their Ingredients?

Unfortunately, Newman’s Own does not provide any specific information regarding where their ingredients come from. A customer service representative from Newman’s Own has been quoted saying that the ingredients used in Newman’s Own Organics pet food are human-grade and largely sourced from the United States but, again, no specific information has been made available.

Newman’s Own Dog Food Recall History

According to the FAQ section of the Newman’s Own website, all of Newman’s Own pet products are manufactured to the highest quality standards and each production run is thoroughly tested for safety.

While the company provides little information about where they get their ingredients or where their products are made, it is good to see that the brand has yet to be affected by a single recall.

Is the brand expensive?

The Newman’s Own brand of dog food is not the most expensive dog food on the market but it will cost you a little more than you’d pay for an average kibble. Prices vary from one recipe to another, but generally a 25-pound bag of Newman’s Own dry dog food will cost you between $50 and $75.

You can purchase Newman’s Own wet food in 5.5-ounce and 13.2-ounce cans which are typically sold in 24-packs or 12-packs. For a 12-pack of 13.2-ounce cans of Newman’s Own Organics wet dog food you will pay between $25 and $50 which gives you an average price of around $3.10 per can.

For a 24-pack of 5.5-ounce cans, you’ll pay $35 to $68 which is an average of $2.15 per can.

What kind of foods do they offer?

Though Newman’s Own offers a wide variety of products for people, their pet food offerings are much more limited. This time, they only have one variant of dry dog food, which is an adult formula.

They have a larger selection of canned food products. Depending where you purchase the products from, the label may carry the Newman’s Own name or the Newman’s Own Organics name.

Newman’s Own has a wide selection of dog treats that come in different flavors, textures, and even targeted nutrition such as joint and skin support treats.

 

Dry Products

The Newman’s Own brand of dog food only offers two recipes for dry dog food – Adult Dog Formula and Advanced Dog Formula.

The first of these offers an ideal protein-fat ratio to support the nutritional needs of adult dogs and it features protein-rich chicken as well as digestible whole-grain carbohydrates.

The second recipe is a high-protein recipe designed for active dogs as well as puppies and senior dogs. Here is a list of Newman’s Own dry dog food recipes:

Dry Recipes:

• Adult Dog Formula
• Advanced Dog Formula

Canned Products

Although Newman’s Own only offers only one kind of dry dog food, they offer a decent number of grain-free and grain-inclusive wet food options.

Newman’s own canned recipes are poultry based, with chicken and turkey options, as well as multi-protein ones that include ocean whitefish. Their canned dog food recipes are as follows:

Canned Recipes:

• Organic Chicken & Liver Dinner for Dogs (grain-free)
• Organic Chicken Dinner for Dogs (grain-free)
• Organic Turkey & Liver Dinner for Dogs (grain-free)
• Organic Turkey Dinner for Dogs (grain-free)
• Chicken & Brown Rice Dinner for Dogs
• Chicken Dinner for Dogs
• Turkey & Brown Rice Dinner for Dogs
• Turkey & Chicken Dinner for Dogs

Dog Treats

While Newman’s Own brand of dog food offers a very limited selection of dry foods, they have a larger selection of dog treats to choose from. Newman’s Own offers dog treats in various flavors.

Whether your dog prefers crunchy biscuits, meaty jerky treats, or soft, easy to chew ones, Newman’s Own has one for him.

Treats:

• Beef Jerky Beef & Sweet Potato
• Snack Sticks Chicken Recipe Grain-
• Turkey & Sweet Potato Flavor
• Grain-Free Chicken Hip & Joint Snack Sticks Dog Treats
• Snack Sticks Chicken & Sweet Potato Recipe Grain-Free Dog Treats
• Dog Biscuits Bacon Flavor Dog Treats
• Turkey Jerky Original Recipe Dog
• Grain-Free Salmon Skin & Coat Snack Sticks Dog Treats
• Chicken Jerky Original Recipe Dog Treats
• Organics Snack Bites Beef Recipe Grain-Free Dog Treats
• Organics Snack Bites Turkey Recipe Grain-Free Dog Treats
• Organics Snack Bites Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Dog Treats
• Chicken Flavor Medium Size Dog Treats