Holistic Select Dog Food Reviews [Updated May 2023]: Best Holistic Pet Food?

Holistic Select dog food is a brand dedicated to the comprehensive treatment of digestive issues, giving your pet the best chance at being able to stay healthy and energetic all day long. It uses a blend of premium ingredients and probiotics for robust digestive support.

Each recipe is made in the United States from carefully sourced ingredients. The company is dedicated not only to providing you with the best possible ingredients but also giving back to the community through well-pet initiatives and programs designed to get every dog the best nutrition.

Let’s see if Holistic Select could be the answer to your dog’s digestive issues, come and read our comprehensive Holistic Dog Food Reviews below.

Brand Quick Look

• Parent Company: WellPet LLC
• Founded in: 2000
• Made in: Mishawaka, Indiana, USA
• Made by: Wellpet Manufacturing
• Available at: Chewy, Amazon, Walmart
• Types of Food: Dry, wet
• Real Meat in First 5 Ingredients? Yes
• Recalled in Past? No

Behind the Brand

Holistic Select was officially debuted in 2000, but the company goes back much farther than that in different forms. It was founded in 1926 under the name Old Mother Hubbard. The idea was born back in 1873 at a bakery that made biscuits for pets.

Old Mother Hubbard was purchased by a pet expert in the 1960s and turned into a thriving holistic pet food option by 2000 when Holistic Select was officially introduced. It falls under the umbrella of WellPet LLC, a collection of holistic pet food companies dedicated to making your pet’s life easier through simple recipes and proper digestion.

The company is one of the top brands of holistic dog food in the country, providing recipes that help alleviate long-suffering dogs’ troubles and provide excellent sources of nutrition that customers can trust. They believe in simplifying ingredients and the power of great probiotics for the unique canine biome.

The company sources ingredients from trusted providers in North America and manufactures food is a facility with high-quality standards and frequent checks. Their foods pass rigorous safety standards and never use cheap ingredients for fillers common for bargain dog food brands.

Holistic Select Dog Food Reviews

1. Holistic Select Adult Chicken Meal & Brown Rice Recipe
2. Holistic Select Adult Health Duck Meal Recipe
3. Holistic Select Senior Health Chicken Meal & Lentils Recipe
4. Holistic Select Weight Management Chicken Meal & Peas Recipe
5. Holistic Select Large & Giant Breed Puppy Lamb Meal & Oatmeal Recipe
6. Holistic Select Small & Mini Breed Adult Anchovy, Sardine & Chicken Meals Recipe
7. Holistic Select Beef Pate Recipe
8. Holistic Select Lamb Pate Recipe

 

1. Holistic Select Adult Chicken Meal and Brown Rice

Overall Brand Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars
First 5 Ingredients: Chicken Meal, Brown Rice, Rice, Oatmeal, Chicken Fat

The Chicken Meal and Brown Rice Health formula is designed to boost your dog’s immune system through a specific and targeted blend of pro and prebiotic support. It helps with digestion and uses enzymes to help dogs break down difficult portions of the recipe including protein and starches.

Whole veggies and fruits provide excellent sources of vitamins and minerals to boost different body systems while giving your dog plenty of fiber to help with digestion. It also has an outstanding balance of whole grains to help your dog feel energetic throughout the day without adding in extra calories that can cause unnecessary weight gain.

Superfoods contain antioxidants to help give your dog the building blocks for good health and well-being. It’s a unique blend that specifically targets the digestive system so that the food is broken down well and easier than it would be without the presence of probiotics and enzymes.

The kibble is a good size and should be satisfactory for most dogs. Pickier dogs may not like the taste of the kibble, but sometimes using one of Holistic Select’s wet foods on top can help encourage your dog to eat. We love that it’s balanced and still contains those little extras to make digestion easier.

One really good thing about this food is that it doesn’t contain any potatoes or peas, which may have a link to a condition known as Canine Dilated Cardiomyopathy. We aren’t sure of the exact relationship, but it’s thought that foods heavy in potatoes and peas could have a link to an increased risk. You don’t have to worry about that with this food, however.

It uses no artificial flavors or preservatives, and there are no cheap fillers such as corn or soy. This allows your dog to have energy all day without adding empty calories that can make weight control difficult. It does have chicken, so be watchful if your dog has allergies already because chicken can be an allergen as well.

This is an excellent, high-quality food that really does help improve your dog’s digestion and overall health. We enthusiastically recommend it for all dogs. The company’s initiatives are excellent, and they’ve had such a good run with manufacturing that we don’t think you’ll have any issues with your dog and this food.

2. Holistic Select Adult Duck Meal Recipe

First 5 Ingredients: Duck Meal, Chickpeas, Peas, Lentils, Chicken Fat

Holistic Select Adult Health Duck Meal Recipe is a grain-free dry dog food formulated to provide the nutritional needs of adult dogs of all breeds and sizes. This duck meal recipe is one of the highest rated products from Holistic Select. Like all of their recipes, this dry food focuses on digestive health.

At 29% protein, this recipe provides all the amino acids needed by adult dogs to keep a lean muscle mass. Duck meal is its main source or protein. Duck meal is a highly concentrated protein source. You can be assured that your dog gets only high quality nutrition with this recipe.

As duck meal is the only animal protein in this recipe, it is ideal for dogs who are sensitive to other animal meat proteins. Chickpeas and lentils provide additional sources of proteins.

The main sources of carbohydrates and fiber in this meal are highly nutritious fruits and vegetables. As it is a holistic recipe, wholesome produce that are beneficial to digestion are added. This includes pumpkin and papaya. These ingredients are rich in soluble and insoluble fiber that help improve digestion.

Many experts believe that a good gut health is the key to a strong immune system and good overall health. Having a healthy digestive system allows the body to absorb more nutrients, instead of turning them to waste.

Holistic Select Adult Health Duck Meal Recipe has prebiotics, probiotics, and live yoghurt cultures that stimulate the growth of good gut bacteria to support the breakdown and absorption of key nutrients. Digestive enzymes in this formula also help in breaking down the vitamins and minerals in this food.

Plants-based ingredients that are rich in antioxidants are also included in this recipe. Antioxidants support the immune system and cellular health. Ingredients such as cranberries, blueberries, and pomegranate are superfoods that provide antioxidants in this recipe.

Holistic Select Adult Health Duck Meal Recipe’s source of healthy fat is chicken fat. It is a highly digestible animal fat that is high in omega 6 fatty acids. This essential fatty acid helps promote good skin and coat health. Chicken fat also gives this duck recipe even more flavor.

Duck is a protein that has lots of flavor. It is no surprise that a lot of dogs love the taste of Holistic Select Adult Health Duck Meal Recipe Dry Dog Food. Aside from the rich, savory flavor, the kibbles are also just the right size even for smaller breeds. This dry kibble has passed the strict standards of some very picky pups.

If you have a picky dog, this recipe could be the one for your pup. It is also great for dogs who have digestive issues, as it has natural ingredients that help give dogs healthy digestive systems.

3. Holistic Select Senior Chicken Meal & Lentils Recipe

First 5 Ingredients: Chicken Meal, Chickpeas, Peas, Lentils, Dried Ground Potatoes

Holistic Select Senior Health Chicken Meal & Lentils Recipe is a grain-free dry dog food formulated to meet the unique needs of older pups. Senior dogs need more joint support, and they need food that is easy to digest. This recipe helps improve the digestion of senior pups for better nutrient absorption.

At 28% protein, it is quite high in protein. This helps keep less active senior dogs keep a leaner muscle mass. With chicken meal as the main source of protein, you can rest assured that your dog gets only high quality concentrated meat protein.

Chickpeas and lentils provide additional sources of protein. The main source of carbohydrates are dried ground potatoes. These are grain and gluten free sources of carbs that are ideal for dogs sensitive to grains and gluten.

To support senior pups’ joint health, glucosamine hydrochloride and chondroitin sulfate are included in this formula.

It also has healthy plant-based ingredients that are high in fiber and antioxidants, such as pumpkin, cranberries, apples, papayas, and blueberries among other nutritious ingredients.

Holistic Select formulas come with a lot of natural ingredients that are designed to improve dogs’ gut health. The pumpkin and papayas in this recipe are very good for digestion. They are high in soluble and insoluble fiber that helps things to move along the digestive tract.

This recipe for senior pups also has prebiotics, probiotics, and live yoghurt cultures that stimulate the growth of good bacteria in the gut to support the breakdown of key nutrients. Digestive enzymes in this formula also help in breaking down the vitamins and minerals in this food. This helps the body absorb even more nutrients.

It has chicken fat that is rich in essential fatty acids that help promote skin and coat health. Chicken fat also gives this recipe a boost of meaty flavor.

Stimulating older dogs' appetites is very important. As dogs get older, they ten to become picky with flavors and textures. Even dogs who were once eating machines would sometimes start preferring certain foods over ones that they used to like.

This dry dog food has received good feedback from owners of older pups. Many of the dogs love the rich chicken flavor of the kibbles. They have also shown more energy since being switched to this recipe.

Picky senior dogs who have started losing weight have gained healthy amounts of weight, and possibly muscle mass with this chicken meal recipe.

Despite the higher price, numerous pet parents find good value in this recipe as it has helped their older dogs get their appetites back, and are now thriving on this food. They also love the high quality, natural ingredients that go into this formula.

Overall, this is highly recommended for older pups. Good digestion is something that senior dogs need, and this recipe has multiple digestive benefits in each serving.

4. Holistic Select Weight Management Chicken Meal & Peas Recipe

First 5 Ingredients: Chicken Meal, Potatoes, Peas, Lentils, Dried Molasses Beet Pulp

Holistic Select Weight Management Chicken Meal & Peas Recipe is a grain-free dry dog food that is formulated to help extra chunky pups or those with lower activity levels maintain healthy weights. This low fat and low calorie recipe is high in fiber to help dogs feel full until their next meal.

Compared to other Holistic Select recipes, Weight Management formula has a slightly lower protein content at 26%. This is due to lower the calorie intake of overweight or less active dogs. Its main protein source is chicken meal, which is a highly concentrated protein source.

Chicken is also one of the most popular flavors among dogs. Not only is it tasty, but it is also highly digestible. This recipe contains sources of Protease to help break down proteins, Cellulase which help break down cellulose, and Alpha-Amylase to help break down starch. It also has L-carnitine to help support dogs’ metabolism and burn more fat.

Aside from helping dogs trim down some excess pounds, this recipe also focuses on digestive health. It has probiotics, prebiotics, and digestive enzymes that stimulate the growth of healthy gut bacteria to support the breakdown and absorption of key nutrients for optimal nutrition and immune function.

This grain-free recipe has wholesome vegetables and fruits that are rich in natural nutrients. The main sources of carbohydrates are potatoes and peas. Lentils also contribute to this recipe’s protein content. Pumpkin and papaya have many digestive benefits.

This recipe also includes cranberries, apples, blueberries, and pomegranate among others which are all rich in natural antioxidants. Antioxidants promote cellular health and help strengthen the immune system.

Like all Holistic Select recipes, this weight management formula is made of natural ingredients. This grain-free recipe contains no gluten, corn, or soy. It is free from artificial enhancers such as flavors, colors, or preservatives.

Aside from the naturally present nutrients, this dry dog food is also fortified with vitamins and minerals to ensure complete and balanced nutrition in every serving.

According to feedback from pet parents, this dry dog food is quite popular among dogs. They love the meaty chicken flavor of the kibbles.

It has also been great for dogs with sensitive stomachs. They are able to keep this food down without upsetting their tummies. This formula from Holistic Recipe seems to have given a lot of dogs more energy. Many have shown increased activity levels since they were fed this recipe regularly.

It has helped many dogs keep their weights down as well. The dogs’ lighter weights are likely to contribute to their increased energy, too. Some dogs have seen an improvement in their skin and coat health.

This is a highly recommended dry food for dogs who need to maintain a healthy weight, or if they need to lose a few excess pounds. It has given numerous dogs so many good health results. This recipe is definitely worth a try.

5. Holistic Select Large & Giant Breed Puppy Lamb Meal & Oatmeal Recipe

First 5 Ingredients: Lamb Meal, Chicken Meal, Oatmeal, Brown Rice, Barley

Holistic Select Large & Giant Breed Puppy Recipe is a grain-inclusive dry food made especially for big puppies. Growing puppies need a lot more nutrition as their bodies are still developing. Large and giant breed puppies are no different. They need just the right amount of protein to help them develop strong and lean muscles.

With lamb meal as the first ingredient, you can be confident that you are feeding your big little puppy only high quality protein with every meal. Lamb is a great choice if you have a puppy who is sensitive to chicken or fish proteins.

It has DHA from salmon oil that supports healthy brain and eye development. This recipe is also rich in omega 3 and omega 6 fatty acids that help promote healthy skin and coats.

Aside from salmon oil, this puppy food’s main source of fat is chicken fat. Chicken fat is not only rich in essential fatty acids, but it is also in flavor. It gives the kibbles a boost of chicken goodness that dogs love.

If your pup is sensitive to chicken, it is actually the protein and not the fat that usually triggers an allergic reaction in some dogs. It is best to consult your vet if you suspect that your dog has allergies.

It also contains sources of Protease to help break down proteins. It also has cellulase that help break down cellulose, and Alpha-Amylase to help break down starch.

The main sources of carbs in this puppy food are oatmeal, brown rice, and barley. These are all easy to digest carbs that are also high in fiber. Fiber helps large breed pups feel fuller and not overeat.

If your puppy has digestive issues, this recipe could be of great help to him. This lamb meal recipe has probiotics, prebiotics, and digestive enzymes. These stimulate the growth of healthy gut bacteria to support the breakdown and absorption of nutrients. Good absorption of nutrients is vital in the development of young puppies.

Holistic Select Large & Giant Breed Puppy Health Lamb Meal & Oatmeal Recipe has naturally nutritious fruits and vegetables, such as pumpkin, papaya, cranberries, apples, blueberries, and dried kelp among others. The nutrients present in these plant-based ingredients help support the overall health of pups.

This grain-inclusive Holistic Select formula contains no artificial ingredients such as flavors, colors, or preservatives. It has no corn, wheat or soy.

Feedback for this dry puppy food has been mostly positive. A lot of puppies love the rich lamb flavor. It has also been credited with improving the digestion of many puppies.

However, it has also received a few comments regarding the hardness of the kibbles. A few young pups find the kibbles a bit hard to chew. Somepicky puppies are also not fans of the lamb flavor.

Overall, those who liked it seem to be thriving. They have better stool quality and are able to keep this food down without upsetting their stomachs.

6. Holistic Select Small & Mini Breed Adult Anchovy, Sardine & Chicken Meals Recipe

First 5 Ingredients: Anchovy and Sardine Meal, Chicken Meal, Peas, Chickpeas, Chicken Fat

Holistic Select Small & Mini Breed Anchovy, Sardine & Chicken Meals Recipe is a grain-free dry dog food formulated for the nutritional needs of small breed adult dogs. Its protein and fat levels are designed to specifically support small breed dogs’ caloric needs.

This has a higher protein content compared to the previously reviewed recipes from the brand. At 35 % protein, this fish recipe has more than enough protein to sustain the higher energy levels of small pups.

Canine fish fans are sure to love this recipe. With anchovy and sardine meal as the most plentiful ingredient, this Holistic Select recipe is packed with a lot of flavor. It also has chicken meal which gives it even more savory flavor. Both protein sources are high quality, easy to digest proteins.

It has peas and chickpeas as the main sources of carbs. They are relatively lower in carbohydrates compared to potatoes and grains. They also contribute to the protein content of this dog food.

Other fruits and vegetables are also included for their high nutritional value. This Holistic Select recipe for small dogs includes superfoods such as cranberries, apples, blueberries, and pomegranate among others. These are foods that are rich in antioxidants that support cellular health.

Like all holistic formula dog foods, this puts focus on improving digestion. It has pumpkin and papaya that are both high in soluble and insoluble fibers that help move things along the digestive tract.

This recipe also has prebiotics, probiotics, and live yoghurt cultures that stimulate the growth of good bacteria in the gut to support the breakdown of key nutrients. Digestive enzymes in this formula also help in breaking down the vitamins and minerals in this food. This helps the body absorb even more nutrients.

This Holistic Select recipe has omega 3 fatty acids from salmon oil and flaxseed to promote healthy skin and lustrous coats.

This dry food for small breed pups contains sources of protease to help break down proteins, cellulase that help break down cellulose, and Alpha-Amylase that help break down starch.

According to feedback from owners of little dogs, their dogs absolutely love the super flavorful kibbles of this product. The small size of the kibbles make it easy for tiny pups and even little senior dogs to chew.

While it has also received feedback that it gives their dogs fish breath, a few said that their dogs’ breaths smell minty after meals.

This has been great for dogs with sensitive stomachs. It has also improved the digestion of those who were previously suffering from various digestive issues.

If you have a picky pint-sized pup, this dry dog food is highly recommended. It is easy to chew, easy on the tummy, and is full of fish and chicken flavors.

7. Holistic Select Beef Pate Recipe

First 5 Ingredients: Beef, Beef Broth, Pork Liver, Whitefish, Ground Dried Peas

Holistic Select Beef Pate Recipe Canned Dog Food is a grain-free wet dog food in loaf form. This high protein beef recipe is packed with meaty flavor, nutrients, and multiple digestive benefits. It is a tasty way to add more hydration to your dog’s diet.

With real beef as the most plentiful ingredient, you can be assured that your dog gets only high quality protein with every meal. While it is called a beef recipe, it is actually a multi-protein formula. It has pork liver and whitefish as additional sources of protein. These ingredients also make this pate even richer and tastier.

Ground dried peas are the main source of carbs in this pate recipe. Potato protein contributes to some of its protein content. This pate has omega 3 fatty acids that promote healthy skin and shiny coats.

Like its dry food counterparts, it also has highly nutritious plant-based ingredients. This time, the superfoods are in powder form. It has cranberries, blueberries, apples, pumpkin, chicory root, and pomegranate among others, all in powder form. These ingredients help strengthen the immune system and improve dogs’ overall health.

Holistic Select Beef Pate Recipe has natural fiber that helps move food through the digestive tract. It has prebiotics, probiotics, and live yoghurt cultures that stimulate the growth of good bacteria in the gut to support the breakdown of key nutrients.

Digestive enzymes in this formula also help in breaking down the vitamins and minerals in this food. All of these help the body absorb even more nutrients.

This Holistic Select beef pate is grain and gluten free. It has no corn, wheat, or soy. It contains no artificial ingredients such as colors, flavor, or preservatives. This canned dog food is free from carrageenan.

Carrageenan is an additive typically found in wet pet foods. Some experts claim that it may potentially contribute to certain medical conditions in pets.

This is a hit among dogs. They love the rich tasting pate. It’s soft texture makes it easy for even senior pups to enjoy. Even finicky dogs seem to love this rich loaf.

Dogs with sensitive stomachs and allergies have also thrived on this beef recipe. They are able to keep it down without any issues. It also does not trigger any allergic reactions in these dogs. Some have even reported noticeably healthier skin and shiny coats in their dogs. Overall, this is another highly recommended food from the brand.

8. Holistic Select Lamb Pate Recipe

First 5 Ingredients: Lamb Broth, Lamb, Whitefish, Lamb Liver, Pork Liver

Holistic Select Lamb Pate Recipe is a grain-free pate formulated for the nutritional needs of adult dogs of all breeds and sizes. This flavorful pate is high in protein from real lamb, and filled with multiple health benefits from other naturally nutritious ingredients.

Lamb is one of the protein sources that are great for dogs with certain protein allergies such as sensitivity to beef or chicken proteins. Lamb is naturally filled with rich flavors, which makes it highly palatable.

Aside from lamb, this recipe also has pork liver and whitefish. If your dog is sensitive to fish, you may want to consider a different recipe, preferably a limited ingredient one.

Lamb liver, pork liver and whitefish gives Holistic Select Lamb Pate Recipe even more flavor and a richer texture as well. As it is enriched with vitamins and minerals, it is nutritionally balanced and complete. It can be served on its own as a meal, or as a kibble topper to stimulate your dog’s appetite and add more hydration to his diet.

Its carbohydrates come mostly from peas. It is supported by other plant-based ingredients such as apples, cranberries, blueberries, pumpkin, blueberries, and others in powder form. These ingredients are rich in antioxidants that help strengthen the immune system. It also has omega 3 fatty acids from flaxseeds that promote healthy skin and shiny coats.

As it is a holistic formula, this lamb pate has multiple ingredients that all support digestion. A healthy gut makes the body absorb nutrients better. It has pumpkin and papaya powders that are high in fiber. Fiber helps move food along the digestive tract.

Holistic Select Lamb Pate Recipe has prebiotics, probiotics, and live yoghurt cultures that stimulate the growth of good bacteria in the gut to support the breakdown of key nutrients. Digestive enzymes in this formula also help in breaking down the vitamins and minerals in this food. All of these help the body absorb even more nutrients.

This natural wet dog food is grain and gluten free. It has no artificial enhancers like flavors, colors, or preservatives. It is free from additives such as carrageenan. Some experts claim that carrageenan may potentially contribute to certain medical conditions in pets.

According to feedback from pet parents, dogs love Holistic Select Lamb Pate Recipe Grain-Free Canned Dog Food. As it is quite tasty, it is very effective in getting the dogs to take their pills. The pups gobble up every morsel of this rich pate.

Aside from their dogs enjoying this lamb pate, their owners purchase it because of the high quality ingredients that go into every can. They are confident that they are feeding their dogs only natural and nutritious food with this pate.

Many dogs who previously had digestive issues with their old food are thriving on this recipe. This Holistic Select lamb pate does not upset their tummies, and their stool quality have significantly improved.

 

What Types Of Dog Food Does Holistic Select Offer?

Holistic Select offers a few different lines of food in both wet and dry options. They have life stage-specific and breed size specific formulas plus a line for dogs with constant, severe allergies.

Dry Foods

• Adult Health Anchovy, Sardine, and Salmon Meal
• Adult Health Chicken Meal and Rice
• Adult Health Lamb Meal and Rice

Grain Free

• Adult And Puppy Health Salmon, Anchovy, and Sardine Meal
• Adult Health Duck Meal
• Adult Health Deboned Turkey and Lentils
• Adult Heath Rabbit and Lamb Meal
• Large and Giant Breed Adult
• Large and Giant Breed Puppy
• Senior Health Chicken Meal and Lentils
• Adult Small and Mini Breed Health
• Puppy Small and Mini Breed Health
• Weight Management Chicken Meal and Peas
• Puppy Health Anchovy, Sardine, and Chicken Meal
• Large and Giant Breed Adult Health
• Large And Giant Breed Puppy Health

Wet Foods:

• Grain Free Beef Pate
• Grain Free Chicken Pate
• Grain Free Duck Pate
• Grain Free Lamb Pate
• Grain Free Turkey and Duck Pate
• Grain Free Whitefish, Salmon, and Herring Pate

Holistic Select Recall History List:

Holistic Select hasn’t had a recall yet, and because of their rigorous safety standards, we don’t expect they will any time soon. They use only trusted providers and regularly inspect their company-owned manufacturing facilities, so everything is under strict control. Considering they’ve been under this label since 2000, that’s a pretty good run so far.

Our Favorite Recipes

Let’s take a look at a few of our favorites to see if one might be the answer for your pet’s needs. These have achieved high-quality ratings and plenty of customer satisfaction in the past.

Large Breed Adult Health Chicken Meal and Oatmeal

Large breed dogs have unique needs, and the high-quality protein concentrate should help your large breed keep up proper muscle tone without adding in extra calories that can cause weight issues. Using oatmeal is a good source of carbohydrates to provide energy all day.

A proper blend of probiotics for your canine’s gut flora keeps digesting in check and boosts the immune system to help dogs with inflammation or itchy skin.

Omega fatty acids also support skin and coat health while glucosamine and chondroitin promote joint health. Fruits and vegetables round it all out with vital vitamins and minerals.

Senior Health Chicken Meal and Lentils

Your senior dog needs support for aging joints and an aging mind. This formula uses concentrated proteins to ensure proper muscle tone into aging and uses only high quality, natural ingredients for better digestion.

It contains specific enzymes that help break down proteins and starches, making it easier on overall digestion. Glucosamine and chondroitin support aging joints and may help improve their condition. Holistic Select uses a high-quality blend of probiotics suited to your dog’s unique canine flora to help ease digestion and support the immune system.

Turkey and Duck Pate Grain Free Adult Wet Food

The Duck Pate is a rich source of protein and fat that can help picky dogs eat all their meal. It uses high-quality duck proteins and a blend of fruits and vegetables for a high-quality meal that includes prebiotic and probiotic support.

Botanicals and herbs such as chicory root help ease digestion to help dogs that sometimes have trouble with their stools when eating wet foods. It’s great to top off kibble and create a blend of high quality, nutritious food that will also satisfy your dog’s picky tastes.

Customer Reviews

Holistic Select is a very well-liked food with four or more stars consistently across online providers and individual recipes. Customers love that their dogs’ digestion and skin health usually improves on this food and that the probiotic support helps dogs with chronic tummy troubles. It also helps with the immune system.

This is also a consistently high rated food for veterinarians and top dog food raters. It’s well respected and often used as an alternative to cheap foods that have done a lot of damage to a dog’s skin, immune system, and weight.

What Do People Like And Dislike About Holistic Select Food?

People seem to love the simple ingredients and the trust they have that the food is the highest quality. Customers noticed that their dogs digestion improved and the quality of their coat and skin. Most dogs seem to like the taste of the kibble, and if they don’t, the canned foods usually do the trick.

Some customers did note that their senior dogs had trouble chewing the kibble and that the puppy formulas may still cause some gas. If that’s the case, gently introduce the food to your puppy or dog by transitioning slowly from the food they were on to see if that helps. Some dogs are highly picky and may not like a food regardless, but the canned duck recipe often helps with that pickiness.

Some of the recipes use peas as an alternative to grains which may make cause some heart issues in breeds prone to an enlarged heart. Some customers noted that they wished the formulas came in a pea free version to alleviate that danger until we understand more about what’s happening.

Positive

“Our 5 Bearded Collies have been on Holistic Select their entire adult lives. We have never had any digestible issues with the kibble. They love the flavor, and sometimes I use it for treats when training. It is also on the list at Whole Dog Journal as one of the preferred kibbles….” Hector, chewy.com

Negative:

“Two of my three dogs are not finicky eaters, so generally it's not a problem. My border collie is a finicky eater, and he's always been a problem. But now not one of my dogs likes this new formula of holistic select. I have been feeding them this previously, before the product change, there was no issue. But now getting them to eat is like going 12 rounds with Mike Tyson….” pronewsguy, chewy.com